Zamfara, the lowest contributor, received over 5× its input, while Kano, the highest contributor, had the lowest relative gain

Key Takeaways

The North-West region received ₦66.55 billion, more than double its remittance (₦28.31B), showing a heavy reliance on federal VAT sharing.
Zamfara, the lowest contributor (₦1.45B), received the highest percentage gain (+433%), getting ₦7.72B, while Kano, the highest contributor (₦9.59B), had the smallest relative gain (+41.5%).
Kaduna and Katsina, despite remitting ₦3.50B and ₦3.86B, received ₦10.18B and ₦10.01B, respectively, nearly tripling their remittance.
Kano remitted 34% of the zone’s VAT but received only 20.4% of the total allocation, reinforcing that VAT is distributed based on equality and not economic strength.

The VAT distribution in the North-West geopolitical zone of Nigeria highlights a major fiscal imbalance, where states receive far more than they remitted. The region generated ₦28.31 billion in VAT but received ₦66.55 billion, a 135% increase, showing a system where VAT is redistributed to ensure financial balance across states.

Kano, the economic powerhouse of the region, remitted ₦9.59 billion, accounting for 34% of the zone’s total VAT. Yet, it received only ₦13.57 billion, a 41.5% increase. This is the lowest percentage gain in the region, despite Kano being the highest revenue-generating state. In contrast, Zamfara, the lowest contributor at ₦1.45 billion, received ₦7.72 billion, an astonishing 5.3× its remittance (+433%), the highest relative gain in the zone.

Similarly, Kaduna (₦3.50B → ₦10.18B) and Katsina (₦3.86B → ₦10.01B) nearly tripled their VAT remittance in allocation, further emphasising the redistribution formula. The entire region received ₦2.35 for every ₦1 it contributed, confirming that VAT sharing favours equalisation over economic output.

Source:

Federal account allocation committee (FAAC)

<div style="text-align: center;"><a href="https://intelpoint.co/insights/zamfara-the-lowest-contributor-received-over-5x-its-input-while-kano-the-highest-contributor-had-the-lowest-relative-gain/" title="Zamfara, the lowest contributor, received over 5× its input, while Kano, the highest contributor, had the lowest relative gain"><img src="https://intelpoint.co/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/North-west-VAT-remmitance-and-sharing-scaled.webp" style="width: 80%; height: auto; max-width:960px;-ms-interpolation-mode: bicubic; margin: 0 auto; display: block;" alt="Chart: Zamfara, the lowest contributor, received over 5× its input, while Kano, the highest contributor, had the lowest relative gain"/></a><br><span>Find more insights at <a href="https://intelpoint.co/insights?utm_source=Insight%20Embed&utm_medium=HTML&utm_campaign=Zamfara%2C+the+lowest+contributor%2C+received+over+5%C3%97+its+input%2C+while+Kano%2C+the+highest+contributor%2C+had+the+lowest+relative+gain" target="_blank" style="color: #4f9acc; text-decoration: none;">Intelpoint</a>.</span></div>Copied to clipboard!

Period:

January 2025

HTML code to embed chart

Want a bespoke report?

Reach out

Related Insights

The South-West remitted ₦341.18B in VAT but received only ₦106.85B, getting back just ₦0.31 for every ₦1 remitted.

Lagos carried the South-West VAT burden, remitting ₦305.52B (89.6% of the region's total) but receiving only ₦62.59B (20.5% return), making it the highest net contributor in Nigeria.
Osun had the most disproportionate gain, remitting a mere ₦590M but receiving ₦7.73B, an astronomical 1,211% return—the highest redistribution gain in the South-West.
The entire South-West remitted ₦341.18B but received only ₦106.85B, meaning it got back just ₦0.31 for every ₦1 contributed, highlighting a severe VAT allocation imbalance.
Ondo and Ogun remitted only ₦3.3B but received ₦16B combined, far exceeding their generated VAT, while Lagos alone subsidised most of the allocations across the country.

Abia State generated just 1.9% of the South-East’s VAT revenue but took home 18.6% of the total the region received

The South-East remitted ₦10.94 billion in VAT but received ₦39.15 billion, a 257.7% increase, showing a high reliance on VAT sharing.
Abia, the lowest contributor (₦734M), received ₦7.29B, nearly 10× its remittance, making it the biggest relative beneficiary in the region.
Anambra, the highest contributor (₦3.56B), received only ₦8.72B, showing a sharing trend where high-contributing states do not necessarily receive the most.
Every South-East state received at least 2× what they remitted, with an average allocation of ₦7.83B despite an average contribution of just ₦2.19B.

Every North-East state received at least 2× what they contributed (₦46.68 billion in total), a 211.6% increase

The North-East remitted only ₦14.98 billion but received ₦46.68 billion, showing a 211.6% gain due to sharing.
Taraba, the lowest contributor (₦0.94 billion), saw the highest percentage gain (635%) with an allocation of ₦6.91 billion, reinforcing that smaller economies benefit the most from VAT sharing.
Bauchi, despite remitting just ₦2.44 billion, received the highest allocation (₦8.93 billion), a 266% increase, illustrating how VAT is shared based on equality and population, not economic activity.
Every state in the region received at least 2× what they remitted, highlighting the North East’s reliance on VAT sharing and fuelling the fiscal federalism debate on whether VAT should be retained at the state level.

South-west remitted ₦341.38B but received only ₦99.85B

South-West drives Nigeria’s VAT but gets little back. The region remitted ₦341.38B (53%) but received only ₦99.85B (29% return).
South-South remitted ₦121.84B but got ₦52.49B (43% return); Rivers alone gave ₦90.21B but got just ₦11.01B.
The North enjoyed the highest VAT gains, remitting ₦66.18B and receiving ₦161.11B (240% return); the North-West got ₦66.75B from ₦28.31B (235% return).
South-East and North-East got the biggest VAT boost. South-East: ₦10.94B remitted, ₦39.13B received (357.6% return); North-East: ₦14.94B remitted, ₦46.68B received (312.5% return).

Lagos State’s IGR skyrocketed 112% from ₦384.26B in 2013 to a record ₦815.86B in 2023

Lagos State’s IGR grew by 112%, from ₦384.26B in 2013 to a record ₦815.86B in 2023.
Revenue dipped to ₦268.22B in 2015 before recovering and steadily increasing.
A major jump occurred in 2019, with IGR rising from ₦382.18B to ₦646.61B in one year.
Despite a dip in 2022, IGR hit an all-time high in 2023, signalling a strong economic recovery.

The South-South region got back just ₦0.43 for every ₦1 remitted, one of the lowest VAT returns in Nigeria

The South-South remitted ₦121.84B, making it one of the biggest net donors to the national VAT pool.
The region received only ₦52.49B, meaning it got back just 43% of its VAT contributions.
Rivers State alone remitted a staggering ₦90.21B (74% of the region’s total) but received only ₦11.01B (12.2% return), marking one of the worst VAT allocation disparities in Nigeria.
Cross River had the lowest VAT contribution (₦1.55B) but received ₦7.45B, a 380% gain, while Bayelsa, despite remitting ₦12.8B, received only ₦8.02B, less than lower-remitting states like Delta (₦9.05B).
Every state in the South-South received more than it remitted, except for Bayelsa and Rivers, with the latter being the only state to suffer a massive VAT deficit.